The waiting room at Wayne County’s family assistance office on West Lafayette Boulevard smells like burnt coffee and fluorescent light. I was there in late January 2026 following a tip from a social worker named Priscilla, who pulled me aside after a community tax clinic and said, quietly, “There’s a man here you should talk to. He won’t ask for help, but he needs someone to tell his story.” That man was Andre Lombardi.
When I sat down with Andre Lombardi in a side office, he shook my hand with the firm grip of someone who has learned to project steadiness. He is 66, works nights as a security guard at a logistics warehouse on the east side of Detroit, and is raising his 10-year-old daughter, Imani, alone. He wore a pressed button-down shirt on his day off. He did not look like a man in financial distress — which, as he would tell me over the next hour, was precisely the point.
The Refund He Was Counting On
Andre filed his 2025 federal return on February 3, 2026, using a free tax software program he’d been directed to through the IRS Free File program. He filed electronically and selected direct deposit to a checking account he’s held at a local credit union for eleven years. By his calculation, he was owed roughly $3,400 — a figure that included the Child Tax Credit for Imani and a modest refund from overwithholding on his W-2.
“I do everything right,” he told me, without defensiveness, just as a statement of fact. “I keep my records. I have her birth certificate, her school enrollment, everything. I’ve been claiming her since she was born.”
The IRS tool “Where’s My Refund” initially showed the standard “Return Received” status, then moved to “Refund Approved” within the expected 21-day window. Andre checked it every morning before his shift. On day 22, the status stalled. It stayed stalled for weeks.
When the Status Screen Goes Silent
For most electronically filed returns with direct deposit, the IRS processes refunds within 21 days. But a subset of returns — particularly those claiming the Child Tax Credit or the Earned Income Tax Credit — are subject to additional review under the PATH Act, which prohibits the IRS from issuing those refunds before mid-February. Andre’s return included both credits, and he hadn’t fully registered what that meant for his timeline.
By late February, the “Where’s My Refund” tool had shifted to a message he hadn’t seen before: his return was being manually reviewed. No dollar amount was visible. No estimated date. Just a reference number and instructions to wait.
“I called the IRS number,” Andre told me. “I was on hold for over two hours. When someone finally picked up, they said they couldn’t tell me anything beyond what the website said. I just had to wait.” He paused. “I’m 66 years old. I work nights. I don’t have two hours to sit on the phone.”
The Costs That Didn’t Wait
What made the delay genuinely painful wasn’t inconvenience — it was timing. In November 2025, Andre’s homeowner’s insurance carrier had dropped his policy following a water damage claim he’d filed after a burst pipe in his basement. He’d received a payout of $4,100 for that claim, but replacing the coverage proved harder than he anticipated. Several carriers declined to quote him. The one that agreed quoted a premium of $2,340 for the year — up from the $1,180 he had been paying.
Andre had planned to use part of his tax refund to cover the new insurance premium in full and avoid a monthly payment plan that would cost him more over time. Without the refund arriving on schedule, he paid the first month’s installment — $195 — out of his take-home pay of approximately $2,650 per month.
He also sends approximately $200 monthly to his elderly mother in Alabama — a commitment he described not as generosity but as obligation. In the same breath, he mentioned that he hadn’t told his mother about the insurance situation or the delayed refund. “She’d worry,” he said. “She doesn’t need that.”
The IRS Notice That Arrived in March
On March 11, 2026 — 36 days after filing — Andre received a CP05 notice from the IRS by mail. The CP05 is a standard identity and income verification letter; it doesn’t mean a return has been rejected or that fraud is suspected. It means the IRS needs more time to verify income reported on the return, typically cross-referencing W-2 data with employer filings.
“I didn’t know what a CP05 was,” Andre said plainly. “I thought it meant something was wrong with my return. I almost called a tax attorney.” He didn’t — partly because of cost, partly because the social worker at the county office had seen the notice before and walked him through what it meant.
That social worker, Priscilla, was the same person who later connected me with Andre. She told me she sees CP05 notices regularly among her clients — many of whom, like Andre, interpret the formal IRS language as an accusation rather than a processing note.
The Deposit, and What Was Left of It
On April 21, 2026 — 77 days after Andre filed — the $3,400 arrived in his credit union account. He checked his balance at 6:14 in the morning, before his shift ended. He sent me a text that afternoon with no punctuation: “it came”
By the time the refund arrived, the financial math had shifted. Andre had paid $195 in monthly insurance installments for March and April — and a partial amount in February — totaling approximately $545 in installment payments he would not have needed if he’d been able to pay the annual premium upfront. He also incurred a $35 overdraft fee when his phone bill auto-drafted four days before the deposit cleared.
“The money came,” he told me when I spoke with him again in late April. “But I didn’t get to use it the way I planned. That’s just how it goes sometimes.” There was no bitterness in it. Just recognition.
He paid the remainder of the insurance premium. He sent his mother her $200. He set aside $400 for Imani’s summer day camp deposit, which had a May 1 deadline. The rest went to restoring the small buffer he had eroded over the preceding weeks.
What Andre’s Story Reflects in the Broader Data
Andre’s experience is not unusual. According to the IRS filing season statistics, millions of returns claiming refundable credits are subject to additional review each year. The average refund for the 2025 filing season was approximately $3,170 — close to Andre’s amount — but averages obscure the range of timelines that individual filers actually experience.
For lower-income filers who depend on refunds to cover deferred expenses, a delay of 10 or 11 weeks can trigger a cascade: overdraft fees, missed payment discounts, installment premiums, and the quiet psychological cost of not knowing when the money will arrive. These costs don’t appear in any IRS report.
What strikes me most about Andre is not the delay itself — it’s the way he absorbed it. He did not call a hotline in a panic. He did not take out a refund anticipation loan. He trimmed what he could, kept sending money to his mother, made sure Imani’s summer was intact, and waited. That kind of disciplined quiet is easy to mistake for being fine. He was not entirely fine. He was managing.
When I asked him if he’d do anything differently next year, he thought about it for a moment. “Maybe adjust my withholding so I don’t have a big refund coming,” he said. “But I don’t trust myself not to spend it during the year. That refund is like a forced savings account.” He gave a small, dry laugh. “Not a great savings account, I know. But mine.”
He stood to leave, buttoned his jacket, and said he had to pick up Imani from school. It was 3:10 in the afternoon. He works nights. The math of his day — the distance between what he earns and what he needs, bridged by discipline and a refund that took eleven weeks to arrive — stays with me.
Related: After His Wife Retired, Oscar Kirby’s Drug Costs Jumped $340 a Month — Here’s What Happened
Leave a Reply