The conventional wisdom is that a tax refund is a windfall — found money, a government bonus, proof that the system worked in your favor. Robert Yarbrough would like a word with whoever started that rumor. When I spoke with Robert in late March 2026, he hadn’t seen a dime of his expected refund, his prescription costs had tripled overnight, and a workers’ compensation claim he filed six months earlier had just been denied for the second time. His refund wasn’t a windfall. It was a bill he’d already paid — and desperately needed back.
Robert responded to a call-for-sources I posted on social media in early March, asking to hear from people navigating government systems — tax, benefits, insurance — after a major life disruption. His message was brief: “My situation is a mess and I don’t think anyone will care, but here it is.” I called him the next morning. We ended up talking for nearly two hours.
A Year That Unraveled Faster Than He Could Track It
Robert Yarbrough has worked as a custodian for the Omaha Public Schools district for nine years. At 32, he and his wife Sandra — married for just over three years, though he jokes it “feels like 23 in the best way” — were finally in a stable place financially. Sandra, 58, had recently retired from her position as an administrative coordinator after a health scare, leaving Robert as the household’s primary earner. Their combined income in 2025 came in at approximately $91,000 — high enough to disqualify them from most assistance programs, but not high enough to absorb what was coming.
In September 2025, Robert slipped while moving industrial floor buffers in a school hallway. He tore a ligament in his left knee and was prescribed physical therapy and two medications — one for inflammation, one for nerve pain — that he would need for at least six months. The school district’s workers’ compensation carrier initially accepted the claim, then reversed course in November, citing a disputed incident report. Robert was left holding roughly $4,200 in unreimbursed medical expenses.
Then, in January 2026, the school district switched insurance carriers. Robert’s prescriptions — which had been running $45 a month under the old plan — jumped to $340 a month under the new formulary. A refill he picked up in February cost him $380 out of pocket. “I stood at the pharmacy counter and I just stared at the number,” he told me. “I’m not a person who makes scenes, but I almost lost it right there.”
Why He Put So Much Weight on the Refund
Robert filed his 2025 federal return on February 9, 2026, using a paid tax preparer he’s used for four years. Because of his unreimbursed medical expenses and the partial deductibility of those costs under IRS Topic No. 502, his preparer projected a federal refund of approximately $3,380. That number — more than three months of prescription costs — became the figure Robert organized his spring around.
Under normal circumstances, the IRS Where’s My Refund tool shows most electronically filed returns with direct deposit moving to “Approved” within 21 days. Robert checked the tool every morning starting February 16. For eleven days, his return sat at “Received.” Then, on February 27, his status shifted — but not to “Approved.” It moved to a message he didn’t recognize and couldn’t decode.
The Letter That Arrived on a Tuesday
On March 4, 2026, Robert received IRS Notice CP05 in the mail. The notice informed him that the IRS was reviewing his return to verify his income, withholding, and tax credits before issuing a refund. The letter provided no specific reason for the review and gave a general timeline of up to 60 days for the IRS to complete its examination. It also made clear: do not call before that 60-day window expires.
Robert called anyway. He described the experience to me without any softening. “I waited on hold for 47 minutes. The person I got was polite, but she basically read me the letter back. She said she couldn’t see anything wrong with my return and to just wait.” He filed the return with Schedule A itemized deductions — specifically medical expenses — which, according to IRS data cited by the Taxpayer Advocate Service, are among the deduction categories that most frequently trigger manual review flags.
What Robert couldn’t separate, emotionally, was the administrative abstraction of a review delay from the very concrete fact that he was skipping doses of his nerve medication to stretch his supply. “I know the IRS doesn’t know my situation,” he told me. “But that doesn’t make it easier to sit there and watch my bank account and just wait.”
What the System Looked Like From the Inside
Talking with Robert for as long as I did, I noticed something specific about his anger. It wasn’t hot or explosive — it was directionless. He wasn’t furious at the IRS agent who read him his own letter back. He wasn’t even particularly furious at his employer’s workers’ comp insurer, though he had every reason to be. His frustration was with the architecture of a system that seemed designed to make it difficult to know where to even point your complaint.
His workers’ comp appeal is still pending before the Nebraska Workers’ Compensation Court. His attorney — a solo practitioner he found through a legal aid referral — estimates a hearing date sometime in late summer 2026. In the meantime, Robert has been paying out of pocket for one of his two prescriptions and rationing the other.
The Refund Arrived — and the Feeling Was Not What He Expected
On the morning of March 28, 2026, Robert’s bank account showed a deposit of $2,847 from the U.S. Treasury. The IRS had completed its review without requesting any additional documents from Robert. The difference between the projected $3,380 and the $2,847 he received — approximately $533 — stemmed from a recalculation of his deductible medical expense threshold, which his preparer is now reviewing.
When I followed up with Robert by phone that afternoon, I expected some measure of relief in his voice. There was some. But it was quieter than I anticipated. “I paid three bills and put the rest toward the prescriptions,” he said. “I’m glad it came. I’m not going to pretend I’m not. But it’s gone. Like it was never there.”
The workers’ comp appeal hearing is tentatively scheduled for August 2026. If the Nebraska Workers’ Compensation Court rules in his favor, Robert could recover the $4,200 in denied medical expenses — though his attorney has cautioned that outcomes in disputed claims are genuinely uncertain. Sandra’s retirement income is modest; Robert’s custodian salary remains the household’s primary support.
Reporting Robert’s story left me with a particular kind of discomfort that I think is worth naming. He did everything right — filed on time, used a professional preparer, documented his medical expenses, kept his records. The system reviewed him, held his money for 49 days beyond his expected date, returned slightly less than projected, and offered no explanation. His anger at the system is entirely earned. The harder question — the one he’s still sitting with — is what you do with anger when there’s no clear face to put on the thing that’s failing you.
Related: She Turned 67 With $23,000 in Hidden Debt and No Safety Net — How a Missed Medicare Program Changed Everything
Related: We Owed $2,400 in Back Property Taxes After My Husband’s Layoff — One Phone Call Changed Everything
Leave a Reply