Roughly 1 in 5 Americans who experience tax-related identity theft wait more than six months for the IRS to resolve their case, according to estimates from the Taxpayer Advocate Service. For some, that wait stretches well past a year — and the financial damage compounds quietly the entire time.
I met Carlos Velasquez in January 2025 through a referral from the Reedy Creek Community Center in Charlotte, North Carolina. A caseworker there had flagged his situation to our publication after Carlos mentioned, almost in passing during a financial literacy workshop, that the IRS had been sitting on money that belonged to him for over a year. He hadn’t asked for help. He rarely does.
Carlos is 37, a union electrician with a steady job and calloused hands that match his general attitude toward outside advice. When I reached him by phone the following week and then met him in person at a diner off Tryon Street, he spent the first fifteen minutes explaining why he didn’t really need to be interviewed. Then he talked for two hours.
A Refund That Should Have Been Routine
For most of his working life, Carlos’s tax situation has been straightforward. He earns roughly $52,000 a year as a union electrician, files a joint return with his wife, Marisol, and typically sees a refund in the range of $2,800 to $3,600 depending on the year. In early February 2024, he filed electronically through a commercial tax software program, expecting a direct deposit within three weeks.
What came back instead was a rejection notice. The IRS system flagged his return as a duplicate — meaning a return had already been submitted under his Social Security number for tax year 2023.
Carlos told me he assumed it was a software glitch at first. He called the IRS helpline and spent 47 minutes on hold before a representative confirmed what he feared: a return had been filed in his name weeks before he ever opened his laptop.
What Identity Theft Actually Does to Your Taxes
Tax-related identity theft occurs when someone uses another person’s Social Security number to file a fraudulent return — usually to claim a refund before the legitimate taxpayer files. According to the IRS Identity Theft Central, the agency identified approximately 294,000 confirmed identity theft returns in 2023 alone, though advocates believe the true figure is significantly higher when undetected cases are included.
The damage isn’t just financial. Once a fraudulent return is filed, the legitimate taxpayer must submit a paper return, complete IRS Form 14039 (Identity Theft Affidavit), and wait for the agency’s Identity Theft Victim Assistance unit to manually investigate — a process that, as Carlos discovered, can take anywhere from 120 days to well over a year.
Carlos filed his paper return in late February 2024, attached Form 14039, and mailed everything certified to the IRS campus in Fresno, California. Then he waited. And waited.
The Financial Pressure Behind the Wait
What made the delay particularly damaging for Carlos wasn’t just the $3,400. It was the timing. Marisol, his wife of 15 years, had just retired from her administrative position at a local healthcare clinic in December 2023 — earlier than planned, due to a health issue. The household went from two incomes to one almost overnight, and Carlos had been counting on that refund to cover a gap.
Carlos also sends money to his mother and younger sister in Oaxaca, Mexico, on a near-monthly basis — typically $200 to $300 per transfer. That arrangement, which he describes as non-negotiable, meant the missing refund created real strain. He took on two weeks of overtime in March 2024 to compensate, logging 68-hour weeks at a commercial construction site in south Charlotte.
Carlos’s identity theft had deeper roots than just the fraudulent tax return. When I asked him about his credit, he was blunt: a data breach at a company he’d done work for in 2021 exposed his Social Security number, date of birth, and home address. He found out from a collection notice — a medical debt of $1,140 that wasn’t his — and by then, two credit cards had been opened in his name with a combined balance of roughly $4,200.
The Turning Point: An IP PIN and a Long-Delayed Deposit
By August 2024 — six months after mailing his paper return — Carlos had received two IRS letters acknowledging his identity theft claim and informing him the investigation was ongoing. No timeline. No specific amount confirmed. Each letter contained a unique case reference number but little else.
In September 2024, a letter arrived from the IRS assigning him an Identity Protection PIN (IP PIN) — a six-digit number that must be included on all future federal returns to verify his identity. According to the IRS IP PIN program, the number changes annually and is mailed each January to enrolled taxpayers.
The actual deposit — $3,400 exactly, matching the amount on his original return — landed in Carlos’s checking account on April 18, 2025. Fourteen months after his legitimate return was rejected. He confirmed the date with a screenshot he showed me at the diner, scrolling through his banking app with the practiced nonchalance of someone who had long stopped expecting good news.
What Carlos Knows Now — and What He’s Still Skeptical About
When I asked Carlos whether the experience had changed how he approaches taxes, he gave me an answer that felt entirely consistent with everything else he’d told me. He now files on the first day the IRS opens acceptance — typically in late January — uses his IP PIN on every return, and has placed a credit freeze with all three major bureaus. Those are concrete steps, taken on his own, without a financial advisor or a professional’s guidance.
What he hasn’t done is seek formal credit repair or consult anyone about the fraudulent accounts still muddying his credit report. His score, he told me, sits somewhere in the low 580s. He knows. He doesn’t love it. He’s not ready to hand that problem to someone else.
He filed his 2024 return in January 2025, before we even met, using his new IP PIN. It was accepted within 48 hours. His projected refund this year is approximately $2,950. He expects it in February or March — and for the first time in two years, he has no reason to think it won’t arrive on schedule.
When I left the diner that afternoon, Carlos was already back on his phone, fielding a call from a job foreman about a commercial project starting Monday. The $3,400 had already been spent — most of it on a water heater replacement and two months of catch-up transfers to his family in Oaxaca. He mentioned that detail almost as an afterthought. As if the money had never really been about him in the first place.
Leave a Reply